16 gauge steel weighs 2.5 lb /ft^2 so the total lid would be 60 lbs in skin alone
12 gauge aluminum is what I used on the other lid and it weighs 1.14 lb/ft^2 so the lid skin would weigh 27.5 lbs
Are those weights backwards? Have you thought about using even thinner steel? The skin shouldn't be holding any real weight and would just need to be thick enough to not dent too easily.
